Q: Questions re. MRI Spots, Memory Loss, Depression, Anxiety, Lithium
I do not have bipolar disorder, but have depression.....the doctor put me on klonopin for anxiety which I am trying to
wean off of....I am down to .725 and I'm having some withdrawl (sweating,
depression and some insomnia and major memory problems) An MRI was done and I
have some lesions in the white matter of my brain. I am a 65 year old female.
The doctor said the lesions come with age. But if they are small ischemic
strokes how do I know that my memory loss, depression and anxiety did not come
from the lesions? Can I take lithium orotate with the klonopin at night and if
I take the lithium orotate with it cause kidney damage? and will I have to wean
my self off of it if I take it for so many days or weeks?
Dear Ms. L’
Let’s separate your questions to start.
(I’ll duck the diagnostic question regarding how anxiety can or should be
viewed in the context of depression, which is very complicated, though perhaps
How do you know that the memory problems – or depression and anxiety, for that
matter – are not associated with these MRI spots? Or the other way around:
might the spots, perhaps representing some small strokes from too little blood
flow (“ischemic strokes”), be the basis for some or many or even all of your
(for readers not familiar with it -- What is lithium orotate?)
Can lithium orotate be used with clonazepam (Klonopin)?
Can lithium orotate cause kidney damage?
When stopping lithium orotate, is a taper-off phase required?
too-brief answers for some of these questions.
#2. If the
spots are really “ischemic strokes”, they could indeed be related to depression
symptoms. A connection between stroke and depression is well-documented.
could also be the very small white matter spots seen in bipolar disorder, if one
includes bipolar disorder in the mix of explanations for #1 – how to account for
a mixture of depression and anxiety. Including bipolar disorder in the list of
potential explanations is legitimate but complicated. Let’s just say this line
of thought should be included if those spots are not exactly what one would
expect in “ischemic stroke”. In that case they would be related to the mood
problem but not regarded as the cause of depression.
if the white matter spots represent ischemic areas, they could certainly explain
memory problems, at least in part. If they are part of a bipolar process, the
connection between them and memory has not been clearly established.
#3. What is
lithium orotate? the
Wikipedia entry is pretty fair, not too biased in any direction, in
my view there is no reason to even consider using lithium orotate. There is no
evidence for its effectiveness; there are no studies resolving the kidney risk
issue; and there is no routine for monitoring its safety, compared to the rather
well-understood routine for monitoring safety in the use of standard lithium
is going to think this is an unfair dismissal of lithium orotate. For
comparison, try the
fairly balanced view (sounds like it to me anyway) by the amusing author of
CrazyMeds, which addresses #5 with an informal but complete review of the
questions #4 and 6 sort of moot, eh? As for clonazepam though, make sure that
you and your doctor are considering whether the “withdrawal” symptoms you
describe are really withdrawal – unlikely if the reduction in dose is as small
as 0.25 mg – or a return of your symptoms, in which case you might be back to
the question of “what exactly is my mood/anxiety problem in the first place?”
Just in case it might be relevant (I don’t know if that’s true, but just in
case), you might want to review the way in which mood and anxiety mix in bipolar
as a bipolar symptom”.
with the process here; I hope you find an effective solution, whatever its
Published November, 2009