Q: What Should I Use for Sleep : Risks of Toughing It Out &
Sirs, I am a diagnosed BP II on 1500 mg Depakote ER with occasional
insomnia. Mostly I just deal (lots of exercise) w/occasional early morning
awakening and mild depression when it happens, or difficulty sleeping when that
happens (less than 10percent of the time).
I average 6-8 hrs sleep and 90 percent of the time everything is ok. If I
dont sleep (at all) I am a mixed bag of depressive and manic symptoms, and tend
to rapidly cycle. Depressive in the morning peaking around noon and becoming
more manic towards evening.
My question is, I am reluctant to take _any_ sleep medication because I fear
addiction. What should I be using here? I have sonata. That gives me about 2 hrs
sleep which is as good as no sleep. I have Ambien which gives a little more
sleep and tends to cause rebound insomnia. I can also take Trazodone, which I
think will work but is an anti depressant. I can also ask the P-doc for a benzo
but fear them most of all.
What are my risks of just "tuffing it out" and going sleepless once or twice a
month? Will I make the BP worse over time? In my opinion my symptoms are mild I
was late onset BP (45). I was fairly manic for about 6 mos before some
"enlightened" endocrinoligist decided to try giving me 300 mg doses of Trazodone
to fix what he decided was a serotinin deficiency. I then started rapid cycling
and became quite dysphoric. I'd be a suicide now but for a good P-doc who told
me "son, your bipolar II".
Dear Mr. C' --
1. What should you be using for sleep?
Let's come back to that.
2. What are the risks of "tuffing it out" (aka
toughing it out) and going sleepless once or twice a month? Will it make
the BP worse over time?
This latter pair of questions will inform the first
one, yes? So: can going sleepless make BP worse over time? Well, I'm
not aware of any direct data on that question. What we do know:
bipolar disorder gets worse over time in some people, but not all. It seems
that each episode sort of serves as a driver to make subsequent episodes more
frequent and more severe.
Does that apply to you? No way to know for sure
-- unless you had the sense that things were worsening, while you watch. I
agree with the concern about Trazodone on purely theoretical grounds, as an
antidepressant; and obviously much more so on the basis of your experience with
it. Your symptoms may be mild now, but it sounds like they were really
severe at the time you might have been thinking about suicide.
Anyway, sounds like you've got a good doc' so I'd defer
to whatever you and she/he work out, because she/he knows you and your
history. I hope you've had a look at the page on my website about
"dark therapy" (read about
Clocks and Bipolar, then on at the lower part of the section to Biological
Clocks and Treatment), not so much to recommend the 10 hours of enforced
darkness per se, but to make you aware of this tantalizing case history which
seems to say that exposure to late night light could be part of
"cycling" pressures. In my view anyone with rapid cycling should
know about this case report, because the implications for treatment are obvious
and not dangerous: get dimmers for any lights you use after 9 pm, and
don't watch TV or use a computer (your online address suggests this might be an
issue for you?) after 8 or 9 pm. Thus there may be a non-medication
approach to tinker with on your own there.
Now, what should you be using for sleep? Ambien
seems to be pretty good. Some of my patients alternate that with a
benzodiazepine like Ativan (lorazepam) or Restoril (temazepam) and do not seem
to have developed tolerance or habituation (like having withdrawal symptoms when
they don't use it) to either. But in my view, the name of the game is to
treat cycling, not sleep. In my experience, very very few people,
not a one I can think of right now, have sleep problems when they don't have symptoms.
So I target the symptoms, not the sleep. More mood stabilizer, either
raising doses or adding additional medications, is the emphasis I'd urge you to
discuss with your doctor (if that conversation hasn't happened
Published March, 2003